Libertarian presidential nominee Bob Barr, in an op-ed in this morning’s Washington Times, writes, “America is a nation of immigrants, but the process of assimilation has broken down. Although immigration provides economic benefits, it also affects America’s cultural and national identity. Immigration reform must begin with securing the border. Our primary obligation is to protect American citizens. … The federal government first must regain control over the nation´s border. Only then will the U.S. be able to deal with threats of terrorism and infectious diseases, as well as implement a consistent immigration policy. Effective enforcement is more important than a physical fence.”
Barr also writes, “English should be America´s official language. It is not the government’s business what people speak at home. But government business should be transacted English. Congress should scrap bilingual ballots. American citizens should learn enough English to vote. A common language is an important national foundation. While sharply reducing the number of people who enter the U.S. illegally, we should expand legal immigration, especially of those who would contribute the most to America. The unskilled workers and their families coming from Mexico illegally assimilate more slowly, and remain poorer and more dependent on government assistance than past immigrants. Even legal immigrants and their children from the same circumstances use more welfare than native-born Americans.”

The Wild West was NOT anarchy. Courts were not privatized, and there was a mayor in virtually every town–no matter how small. The Wild West as anarchism is an invention–it was minarchist.
There certainly werent sherriffs or mayors EVERYWHERE, but everywhere that there was a population center,there was. =)
The Wild West was anarchy.
For one, there weren’t mayors and sheriffs everywhere. Where there was, the people voluntarily formed mutual confederations — there’s no evidence or reason to believe this equaled a monopoly state.
I repeat: Trent is like a gay guy whose parents knew he was gay from age 3, whose friends all know he’s gay, but hasn’t quite discovered for himself that he is… an anarcho-capitalist!!!
“Since the billionaire’s resources are limited, he would only acquire so much. Now, since trade would be the core of this society, what do you think would happen when people noticed that they couldn’t trade to other people and started losing their business? They would start severing ties to said billionaire. Thus, the information saturation rate also rises.”
Clearly the billionaire doesnt need the financial resources of the small anarcho-capitalist community–that is a given in this example, otherwise why would he even try? Furthermore, even if he DID need their financial resources–he could simply conceal his identity by way of hiring said defense forces DISCREETLY.
“3) They criticize anarchy on the grounds that it would lead to some terrible result, while ignoring the fact that statism already causes that same terrible result, usually to a far greater degree.”
Big government causes the same result as Anarchism, this I agree.
“1) They assume that someone (usually someone rich) would choose to behave in a way that is completely opposed to their own self-interest.”
Preaching to the choir—im a hardcore free trader like yourself. With that said, privatization of the court system leads to laws being enforced only against the poor,as the rich will easily buy their way out of it. A privatized court Judge would do best for his own self-interests by accepting hundred-thousand dollar payoffs.
“1) They assume that someone (usually someone rich) would choose to behave in a way that is completely opposed to their own self-interest.”
Says who? Maybe his goal is to take over that land by force? Maybe he is simply crazy? Maybe he simply hates anarcho-capitalism—it matters not. Some people DO act against their own self-interests.
“We want what went on in the “Wild†West (which, as you’re smart enough to know, wasn’t “Wild†at all). You know that anarchy does not mean the absence of law and order.”
The Wild West was NOT an anarcho-capitalist area–it was a minarchy. Ruled over by local mayors mainly, as well as local law enforcement IN COOPERATION with the local citizenry and private defense forces. Roads and all other transportation were privatized–the courts were not.
Last night my aunt told me I was throwing my vote away – in Spanish. I know that isn’t relevant to anything, but I thought there was a deep and profound ironic connection to this thread that should be shared.
Some days I just hate life.
I think what they are trying to say, Trent, is that you’re overlooking the significance of absolute voluntarism. That kinda demolishes the Outside Force Principle Idea, but not completely.
Since the billionaire’s resources are limited, he would only acquire so much. Now, since trade would be the core of this society, what do you think would happen when people noticed that they couldn’t trade to other people and started losing their business? They would start severing ties to said billionaire. Thus, the information saturation rate also rises.
Voluntarism, the heart and soul of anarcho-capitalism, minarchism, etc., corrects these issues.
Now having said that, there are obviously counters to all these measures here, but for the most part, they work and I won’t go into them. I’m a minarchist like yourself, but that doesn’t mean someday when we are ready to fully dissemble the State, I’ll gladly look forward to an anarcho-capitalist society as well.
Trent – I’ve got way too much football to watch today to get into an argument about anarchy, but sometime later I’ll definitely explain why almost all objections to it are based on 1 of 3 fallacies, which are, briefly:
1) They assume that someone (usually someone rich) would choose to behave in a way that is completely opposed to their own self-interest.
2) They assume that without government, people are somehow totally incapable of coming up with innovative solutions to complex problems, which is, in fact, the greatest strength of the market.
3) They criticize anarchy on the grounds that it would lead to some terrible result, while ignoring the fact that statism already causes that same terrible result, usually to a far greater degree.
I know these responses are vague, but, as I said, I’ll be happy to flesh them out with more details at some point in the future. Just not today.
I’ll have to search the archives for the North article, just from watching the rest of the markets in tandem with the price of gold that does seem the intuitive answer. But I will always dream of one day learning to time these damn things.
Fred – I’ve taken a hit on gold, too. Gary North explained in an article on LRC how gold got overvalued as fiat money flowed into it, creating another asset bubble. Gold can obviously get overbought, as was seen in the early 80s. That said, you buy gold to hold and hedge, not to “make money.” I sure as hell wouldn’t sell now.
Golds about where I bought it a few months back, I probably should have locked in some gains but I don’t think the ship’s sailed yet.
“options trading manual”
Ummm….ya! I know what that means!
😀
Definitely!
*starts sweating*
You’d vote for me in a heartbeat. Don’t lie.
Come on, Trent. You’re smart enough not to conflate chaos with statelessness. Anarcho-capitalists don’t want what’s going on in Somalia. We want what went on in the “Wild” West (which, as you’re smart enough to know, wasn’t “Wild” at all). You know that anarchy does not mean the absence of law and order.
Peter – I’m jamming out the final 1500 words of my 20,000 words options trading manual. Been working on it all day while posting those Angela updates.
Trent – If you believe in personal secession, in the idea that the state may not have a monopoly on any services (including defense and courts), then you are an anarcho-capitalist.
What is a “state”? It is something that is allowed to initiate force to collect taxes and/or prevent competition. You said that I could declare myself a non-citizen, and even form my own alternative defense confederation, etc. The state you advocate then is not a state at all, but a voluntary confederation itself. The state is by definition something you cannot opt out of.
If you fear anarchism, you fear your own ideology being put into practice!
You are like a gay guy who everyone knows is gay but doesn’t know himself.
The key to mastering the English language is practice.
I’m organizing my papers and catching up on the Rally for the Republic speeches.
“Max Raskin’s a punk kid. I’m a wise old man.
Regardless, I’m not here to convert you. You will convert yourself.”
Yea….no.
Max Raskin is a genius, and I won’t put down on him. He is a hell of a lot smarter than me, but too wrapped up in ideology to see reality.
As for me converting myself–the closest I came to anarcho-capitalism was over 2 years ago, and I’v since became a firm minarchist and constitutionalist. I fear Anarchism as much as I fear Fascism or Communism–because the first will devolve into one of the latter two.
Most will claim Somalia isnt based upon capitalist principles–but the traditional anarcho-capitalist understanding is that without a government,the black market would naturally and neccesarily BECOME the market. Besides, what else would it be? Socialism? lol.
Murray Rothbard’s favorite example was midieval Iceland,which he claims was anarcho-capitalist. In point of fact, it was Tribalist–not anarcho-capitalist. If Tribalism is anything, it is minarchist.
“I dont want people associating Freedom or Liberty with Somalia–true anarchy.”
Yet I hear anarchists talking of Somalia as if it’s a utopia.
In respects those two theories, that’s pretty much what I fear out of an anarchist society.
Oh–and I’d never vote for any Anarcho-capitalist.
I dont want people associating Freedom or Liberty with Somalia–true anarchy.
“Based on our earlier debate, where I thumped you btw, you pretty much admitted that you are an anarcho-capitalist. You said that coercive taxation and monopolies are unjust, and that I and others like myself should be free to personally secede. What you advocate is thus not a monopoly state, and thus, you are an anarcho-capitalist. There, pwned. I’m preaching to the converted.”
I admitted that anarcho-capitalism could work on a minimal level and still be a minarchist state. I did not endorse this idea, because it is mostly theoretical. I am a minarchist, in the tradition of Mises, Hayek, Paul, and Jefferson.
Feel free to disprove any of the above scenarios.
Furthermore, the whole idea that a minarchy eventually evolves into big government is absolutely true. Anarcho-capitalism is far worse, transporting directly from pure-freedom to dictatorship or local dictatorship.
GE,
We agree that we have despotism (albiet in a milder form than some) now–I am not an advocate of status quo.
You say that accepting any level of initiation of force is accepting all–this is false. Similarly, would you say that accepting SOME level of orange juice is accepting any and all levels of orange juice? Is filling my glass half-full of orange juice the same thing as filling my entire house with orange juice (thus drowning myself)? No. This is a Rediculousâ„¢ notion.
Thomas Jefferson, Patrick Henry, and Ron Paul all endorse a minimal nitewatchman state—GE would say that they are the same thing as Fascists–because they accept some small level of initiation of force.
I could drive the Billionaire Dictator’s Huge Ass Hummer through the 1980’s Ozone Layer-Size Hole in that logic, Trent. But I have werk to do!
Based on our earlier debate, where I thumped you btw, you pretty much admitted that you are an anarcho-capitalist. You said that coercive taxation and monopolies are unjust, and that I and others like myself should be free to personally secede. What you advocate is thus not a monopoly state, and thus, you are an anarcho-capitalist. There, pwned. I’m preaching to the converted.
Max Raskin’s return to the “The Billionaire Dictator” was: The people pool their cash and hire an assassin, rather than a defense firm–saving money and keeping the contract discreet and a surprise.
My return was basically the “Information Nonsaturation Principle”–how do they contact this assassin? How do they pool their money? How do they discuss this plan amongst everyone? The Billionaire Dictator would obviously restrict (or eliminate) communication and movement, and DEFINETLY monetary transactions.
Max Raskin’s a punk kid. I’m a wise old man.
Regardless, I’m not here to convert you. You will convert yourself.
I can’t get into this debate tonight, but, uh… tyrannical despotism is what we have now. Thinking you can trust the people to form a government to protect themselves from tyrannical despotism is absurd, when the government is the entity that is tyrannical and despotic. Accepting any level of initiating force is accepting all levels. And you know this, man.
GE,
If Max Raskin could not convert me to Anarcho-capitalist, their probably is not much hope for you. An Anarcho-capitalist system is simply a transition system: Into tyrannical despotism controlled by a billionaire/millitary leader or into tribalism.
The Outside Force Principle simply asks the question: What if a wealthy man buys all of the property sourrounding yours? For example: Assume T. Boone Pickens stops pitching his rediculous energy plan and instead turns to conquering fictional anarcho-capitalist communities. Anarchotopia is a city in…Michigan…which is wholly based upon the ideas of Anarcho-capitalism. Pickens buys the property sourrounding this town and does not allow anything past his property–including helicopters overhead, water or gas lines underfoot, or roads on his land. The Anarcho-capitalist system now has no choice but to become fully self-sufficient. Which, in such a small geographic area (and this is important,because even Anarcho-capitalists admit that their system could not work in a large geographical area) means growing a few crops and digging a well–but possibly suffering from starvation or dieing of thirst–and definetly reduced ability to live. Pickens will not allow people to enter, or leave, the town–even charities. Sorry–this town dies and is screwed out of their freedom to boot. And under their system, that is REALLY the only option.
The Information Nonsaturation Variable is another good one. It simply offers the fact that information is not at 100% saturation at this point in time. Anarcho-capitalists often suggest that it is, or inevitably would be under their system. Their is no example here, just somethnig to keep in mind.
Another viable option is probably my favorite. The Billionaire Dictator. This one simply involves hiring highly armed and highly trained mercenaries to enforce a dictatorship. Some anarchists would return with the idea that the town could simply pool funds to hire a better defense firm–but the Billionaire obviously has a higher source of funds and could probably afford to pay several times that amount for the same defense firm to simply do NOTHING, which would be far more profitable for that defense firm. The next solution from the anarchists would be that the civilians could take up arms and fight tooth and nail against that hired firm,and I suppose they could–but it seems to me that they would likely lose and would definetly suffer massive casualites,which they shouldnt have to do in a “free country”.
What a minarchist state (a small government,essentially) gaurantees is some amount of protection of your God given (or Natural) rights. If someone blockades your house, you have an avenue to correct this through a nuetral court. Under the anarcho-capitalist system, you have to buy bigger guns, hire a defense firm, or hire a private judge to make a decision that will likely be ignored by the loser of the suit.
Big Guy with a capital B and G. You know this!
Trent, too, will be an A.C. within 366 days.
I’ve never heard of those.
Google=Nothing.
what exactly are they?
Mike,
Simply resort to “The Outside Force Principle” and the “Information Nonsaturation Variable”.
Both easily defeat the whole concept of Anarcho-capitalism.
“Mike Theodore will be an anarcho-capitalist by the time he hits 18. That’s my prediction.”
Bring it, Big Guy. In 3 days, you’ll have one year to do your magic.
I think the anti-immigration pandering and “wetback” ad were some of the biggest mistakes of the Ron Paul campaign.
So naturally, Bob Barr felt compelled to go the same route. He wants Ron Paul supporters but only emulates the bad stuff.
The main issues, to me any way, are/were economics/monetary policy, and being anti-WarS. Barr fails on those and everything else is just fucking around the margins and losing badly.
I believe English is the dominant language in science. I know English is dominant language in computer science and Engineering. English has the vocabulary that most other languages lack — pretty much all computer-related/technical words in other languages are loanwords from English.
Now, how that dominance came into being is a different matter. I’m not sure how much market selection had to do with it.
—
On the subject of English as a national language: It doesn’t really matter too much to me, but it’s not very libertarian. The idea certainly should not be supported, but there’s no point in getting vehemently upset or outraged when it is.
German is much more suitable for conveying scientific concepts than English is.
And I’ve heard from pilots that Italian would work better for speaking to the tower. The market didn’t choose the best language for the job, it chose the one in use by the dominant military forces of the time and inertia’s kept it there.
Mike Theodore will be an anarcho-capitalist by the time he hits 18. That’s my prediction.
English is the language of trade, but I do not believe it is the proper language of Science. German is much more suitable for conveying scientific concepts than English is.
The whole discussion of whether to make English (or any other language) “official” should turn the stomach of a Libertarian. English is the language of science. It is the language of trade. An Italian pilot landing a plane in Argentina speaks to the tower in English. A Chinese trader in Turkey speaks English. No one had to pass a law to make English the international lingua franca. It happened because English best met the needs of the multilingual market. As long as that continues to be true, people will learn English to advance in life. If that ever ceases to be true, then no law will force it to become true. It is analogous to the dominance of gold as a medium of exchange, long before there were nation-states to mandate a standard.
Pretty much the same, but hopefully rubbing it off on my US History students.
BWAHAHAHAHA!
You’re 16, and you’re that paranoid?
When I was 16, I thought almost all Americans studied every candidate, in every election (including all the minor candidates, judges, county assessors, etc.), and made a conscientious decision to vote for the best candidate, irrespective of party affiliation, ethnicity, religion, sex, etc.
When I was 16, I believed in the nobility and idealism and goodwill of my fellow
American.
It took me 30 years to reach my level of cynicism. But if you’re already that paranoid and cynical at 16, what will you be like in your forties?
Well, I obviously am. This is pretty paranoid for a non-anarchist, though. 🙂
No one said anything about giving cops authority to “bust up people” for speaking Spanish.
Nor do I believe that printing English-only ballots will lead to that. Even I’m not that paranoid.
Well, what I fear out of “handling” is local cops busting up people for speaking spanish in a government building. Improbable maybe, but do you trust giving them that authority?
Mike Theodore: “I don’t even think they should be “handled†at all.”
That may be possible under anarchy, but so long as there is govt, the issue of language will be “handled” one way or another.
Whenever the govt sets up schools, prints ballots, issues paperwork, hires translators, or passes anti-discrimination laws concerning a person’s language, then govt is “handling” the language issue.
By its very existence, govt “handles” the language issue, passively or not. If there is govt, the issue cannot be avoided.
Mike,
Local governments will conduct business. The business they conduct they’ll print in some language or another. Maybe officially, maybe not–but thats what I mean by “handling”
“Language is not the concern of the federal government–these things should be handled locally.”
I don’t even think they should be “handled” at all.
Wow. This is crap that I expect from the CP, not LP. The CP once passed a resolution trying to make English the national language and although it was fought by the Decentralists (myself, Idaho, Texas, California, Arizona)–it passed.
Language is not the concern of the federal government–these things should be handled locally.
Government business (if there’s going to be any) should only be conducted in one language. I don’t particularly care what language they choose, but printing ballots and forms in multiple languages, hiring translators, etc. just gives the state another excuse for stealing and spending money that doesn’t belong to them.
In most areas, English is the most common language, but obviously there may be exceptions in certain communities, so those communities can choose Spanish (or whatever). Hell, I wouldn’t mind if we made Spanish the official language for the entire nation. It might cause people not to rely on the state so much.
And Bob Barr, the supposed “states’ rights” advocate, DOESN’T.
Mike Theodore finally gets the idea of federalism/decentralism!
“We needn’t make English “official†for the nation, but govt business should be in English.”
It already is, and has been for as long as I remember. Try telling a crotchety old senator to speak spanish.
Lets toss this one around: Let’s say there is a small community of a few hundred in the southwest that is made up completely of Mexican immigrants. Let’s say there’s a town meeting, and the mayor knows that everyone in attendance speaks spanish and few know english. Now no one complains when the meeting is in spanish, but what agency should rain on their parade? The FBI? Local law enforcement? Or should a new Federal force be made up to go around busting up townships?
pdsa is right. TMS, who usually is, is wrong.
Why should the federal government have a say over what language ballots are printed in? This is a local decision. What’s more, governments shouldn’t be printing ballots at all.
There’s no need to encourage assimilation. It happens naturally in a free society.
The simple fact that Barr is on my ballot (and Baldwin is not) was tempting me, but I just can’t do it. This guy has no concept of what libertarianism means and the way this government should be run constitutionally. This is just pathetic. I’ll write in Chuck.
@ Thomas M. Sipos – you are very wrong. The Government serves the people, and if the people do not speak English, it should still serve. English is the dominant language, and the citizenry should be encouraged to learn how to use it properly, because without a command of the English language, there is little chance of upward mobility.
@ Steven R Linnabary – Eubonics was an ill-advised plan, but it had nothing to do with a different language. It is still English, just a dialect of it. If we’re going to get into correcting lame dialects, I think Congress should begin with correcting their own first.
WTF?
Even Puerto Rico? A judge this week ordered the (occupied territory, wanna be state, what is it?) entity to print ballots in English as well as Spanish, for the first time.
Is Ebonics a separate language? A few years ago, it was suggested that it be taught in ESL classes, as well as be used to teach certain children.
PEACE
Steve
History says that “assimilation” is exactly the opposite of what makes America peaceful and free. The Balkans, Beirut and Northern Ireland are prime examples of what attempts to forcibly assimilate result in.
America prior to WWII was a patchwork of communities speaking (and voting in) various languages. It still is, but not quite as much, since when putting 16 million men under arms the government found it more convenient to teach them all to understand phrases like “take out that machine gun nest” than to organize them into units with commanders who spoke their languages (the same was not true before — large segments of the Union Army in the war of 1861-65 spoke, and were commanded in, German).
“English-only” would be just another step in the Sovietization of America (one specific reason the USSR maintained the draft was to make Russian-speakers out of its ethnic minorities).
Let’s assimilate Bob Barr into the LP. Otherwise Retard factions pop up and balkanate.
Remember, when you assimilate, you make an ass out if I and milate.
Barr: “It is not the government’s business what people speak at home. But government business should be transacted English. Congress should scrap bilingual ballots. American citizens should learn enough English to vote.”
This part is not unreasonable.
Assimilation helps prevent the U.S. from breaking apart into tribal factions. Learning English should be encouraged, albeit not required.
While not making English “official,” neither should the state subsidize other languages. It should not make it easy to get by without English.
Govt business should be transacted in English. Multi-lingual ballots should go. So too multi-lingual state education.
My position on assimilation.
Open borders will only work if we encourage assimilation. Without assimilation, we become another Balkans, Beirut, or Northern Ireland.
Most humans are tribal. It’s peaceful assimilation or hostile Balkanization.
We needn’t make English “official” for the nation, but govt business should be in English.
Why doe Bob Barr hate Chili and Enchiladas?
English official language?! That does it. I will not be voting for Barr.
The Threat of Infectious Disease? What disease you talking ’bout Barr? Brown Skin?