Press "Enter" to skip to content

Battleground poll: Nader 1.3%, Barr 0.9%

A Tarrance Group Battleground poll of 800 voters across the U.S. conducted September 10-17 offers some details on support for the Libertarian Bob Barr-Wayne Allyn Root and independent Ralph Nader-Matt Gonzalez tickets. When respondents were asked who they planned to vote for, with no options named, Barr was named by 0.3% of respondents, Nader 0.2%, and candidates other than Barr, Nader, and the Democratic and Republican nominees by 1.1%.

When respondents were asked to select between the Barr-Root, McCain-Palin, Nader-Gonzalez, and Obama-Biden tickets, with the vice presidential nominees’ names read as well, Nader-Gonzalez took 1.3% and Barr-Root 0.9%. That question found 0.1% saying they would definitely vote for Nader, 1.1% probably, and 0.1% leaning toward Nader; 0.2% said they would definitely vote for Barr, 0.6% probably, and 0.1% leaned toward Barr. (McCain-Palin led Obama-Biden overall, 47.2% to 45.0%.)

14 Comments

  1. Steve LaBianca September 19, 2008

    I would certainly give Nader a much higher probability of getting a million votes than Barr.

  2. Mike Gillis September 19, 2008

    Yeah, but that total was without Nader being on the CA, IL, MA and a number of big state ballots.

    Considering that he got 21,000 write in votes from CA last time, I expect him to top 100,000 there this time.

    I think a million votes isn’t unthinkable.

    But Barr’s ballot access woes will come back to bite him, as well as thumbing his nose at his base, and he’s likely come in fourth place this time.

  3. Steve LaBianca September 19, 2008

    My recollection of the “official” vote tallies for 2004, which included write-in votes which were actually counted, is that Nader received 465,000, give or take 2 to 3 thousand. Badnarik by comparison received 398,000 + or minus a little.

  4. LaineRBT September 19, 2008

    Nader had just over 400,000 votes in 04 when he was just on 34 and not even on the California ballot. He is on in California this year and 45 state ballots, he will probably be around a million this election cycle.

  5. JimDavidson September 19, 2008

    Nolan P, it is not possible to ascertain whether the 800 persons are a random and representative sample without further examination. Eight hundred is a fairly good size for a national poll. I’ve seen them run larger and a bit smaller.

    You can’t really say whether they were randomly selected without looking at the methodology for selecting them. You can’t say whether they are a representative sample without comparing statistics about them to the population as a whole, such as average income, average age, age distribution, ethnicity, gender, etc. But, most polls that get national coverage are taken seriously by the companies organising them.

    Steve’s view that the blush is off the rose, and Douglass’s view that Palin put the Barr campaign in the hurt locker, along with the thought that a whole lot of Ron Paul’s supporters were deliberately told to…do what Shane Cory told Don Rasmussen to do…are reasonable explanations for the loss in this poll and some other recent polls.

    I do not expect Nader to do very well, but I would say that we can expect Bob Barr to do about as well in comparison to Nader as another candidate for the LP, Harry Browne, did in 1996 and 2000. I think in both cases, Nader got more votes.

    I do not think that Nader getting more votes means that more Americans are socialists. I think it means that fewer Americans who are libertarians see any reason to vote for the LP candidate.

  6. johncjackson September 19, 2008

    Mike Gillis #7 makes the point I was going to.

    Palin only hurts Barr to the extent he was courting a certain type of conservative. Palin is not libertarian at all unless you are a “Dondero libertarian”.

  7. Mike Gillis September 19, 2008

    I also want to say that I hate these open ended Zogby polls.

    Just name the all of the candidates, because it naturally skews every poll toward the majors.

    Our ballots aren’t all write-in, so why should polls?

    Voters might decide to vote Nader/Baldwin/Barr/McKinney after seeing the ballot, having not previously known they were running.

  8. Mike Gillis September 19, 2008

    The Palin nomination hurt Barr because so far he’s aimed his campaign almost squarely at disaffected conservatives, rather than libertarian voters and Ron Paul supporters.

  9. Steve LaBianca September 19, 2008

    Just to follow up on my comment previously, “highlight how real libertarian solutions are the answer to the specific current problems at hand”

    Ron Paul accomplished this very well on several fronts-

    1-The massive fiscal crisis were in right now – solution-end the income tax, severely curb the Fed’s ability to inflate with allowing competing currencies, and end subsidization and socializing cost of lending, among other solutions, which includes . . .

    2-ending the foreign interventionism which costs so much in money, lives and respect from other people around the world.

    I think I’ve made my point.

    Note-how well has Barr picked up on these solutions? Not very IMO.

  10. Steve LaBianca September 19, 2008

    I agree that there is a “Palin effect” on Barr and probably Baldwin’s vote outcome, but the specifics of Palin in 2008, or Perot in 1992, etc isn’t the important point.

    As Mr. Sipos has so succinctly pointed out, if Libertarians see great opportunities in any particular year, so will the other parties. Materially altering the LP strategy for specific “opportunities” is futile.

    The best LP strategy was and always will be to nominate the best “libertarian” candidate, and highlight how real libertarian solutions are the answer to the specific current problems at hand.

    Barr falls way short of this strategy. His impact on the election will likely not be any greater than if the delegates had nominated Ruwart or Kubby. It is possible that the Barr campaign may have a net negative effect on the stature and integrity of the party however. That would almost undoubtedly not happen with Ruwart or Kubby as our nominee.

  11. Nolan P. September 19, 2008

    These polls are full of sh*t. They ask questions in a way that lowball the figures for third party candidates. The Zogby poll is notorious for this.
    And asking only 800 people across the U.S. is far from a representative sample. You could pretty much divide that number in half for Dems and Republicans.

    The most reliable one is the CNN polls.

  12. Thomas M. Sipos September 19, 2008

    Steve’s right. Palin killed Barr.

    The Big Error in Libertarian “strategy” is to always wait for a “perfect storm,” when “the stars align” so that there will be a “window of opportunity” for Libertarians to score big.

    The Error is in this strategy is assuming that Libertarians are the only ones who see this “window of opportunity” and that no one else will either shut the window, or squeeze through it first.

    1992 was supposed to be THE year when Libertarians could win, because conservatives hated Bush and Clinton. But Ross Perot also saw that window, and took it away from the LP.

    Now 2008 was supposed to be THE year when Libertarians could win, because conservatives hated McCain and Obama. But McCain also saw that window, and shut it with Palin.

    The LP should stop relying on astrology, and just run the “best libertarian” candidate, and not the “best voter getting for that window which will soon shut.”

  13. inDglass September 19, 2008

    I attributed Barr’s drop to the Palin nomination and some poor moves by Barr. However, I see Nader dropping too in both state and national polls. I hope that Ron Paul’s efforts generated increased donations and support for third party candidates so that they can reverse this trend.

  14. Steve LaBianca September 19, 2008

    Now that the election is about a month and a half away, with voters beginning to concentrate on the traditional “lesser of two evils” voting criteria, the much hailed 5 and 7 percent for results for Barr, from earlier polls is now a distant memory.

    Look for polls to continue this trend and settle in at 0.6 to 1.0% for Barr. The FINAL poll, at the voting booth will likely yield Barr 0.4 to 0.7%, or something like 500,000 t0 800,000 votes.

    Again I ask, was it worth going for the alleged “star power” of Barr over a true libertarian candidate?

    NOTE: If Barr would have been willing to court the Ron Paul vote, he would likely break one million votes. Not now.

Comments are closed.