Three independent candidates won seats in the New Hampshire Legislature this month, including two who did so after mounting successful write-in campaigns during the state primary in a rare use of electoral fusion.
According to results from the New Hampshire Secretary of State, William Fessenden in Strafford County’s 5th House District, Becky Berk in Merrimack County’s 13th House District, and George Randell in Carroll County’s floterial 8th House District all won their respective legislative races. Fessenden defeated a single Republican challenger in an open two-way race, while Berk and Randell both won in elections that allowed for two winners from a field of four candidates.
In the case of Randell, who narrowly defeated Republican Tammy Garthwaite on Election Day by two votes to win the second of the district’s two seats, his race went to a recount. The recount saw him expand his lead over Garthwaite to 18 votes. He also performed far better than the candidate who appeared on the ballot solely as a Democrat.
All three candidates initially petitioned their way onto the November general election ballot as independents, collecting the required 150 valid signatures to do so. However, in the case of Fessenden and Randell, they were also able to win Democratic Party nominations through write-in campaigns after the party failed to field a full slate of candidates, allowing them to appear on the ballot twice with votes from both appearances combined into a single total.
Election returns from all three races are provided below. Figures are based on information tracked in the New Hampshire Secretary of State’s official spreadsheet as of Tuesday, November 17.
Strafford County 5th House District Results
| Candidate Name | Ballot Designation | Total Votes |
|---|---|---|
| William F. Fessenden | Independent/Democrat | 1,323 |
| Jenny Wilson | Republican | 993 |
| Write-ins | N/A | 2 |
Merrimack County 13th House District Results
| Candidate Name | Ballot Designation | Total Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Becky Berk | Independent | 1,400 |
| Clayton Wood | Republican | 1,383 |
| Paul Twomey | Independent | 1,341 |
| Cyril Aures | Republican | 1,215 |
| Write-ins | N/A | 1 |
Carroll County 8th House District (Recount) Results
| Candidate Name | Ballot Designation | Total Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Colin Mitchell | Republican | 5,379 |
| George Randell | Independent/Democratic | 5,086 |
| Tammy Garthwaite | Republican | 5,068 |
| Jim Pittman | Democratic | 4,687 |
| Write-ins | N/A | 16 |
New Hampshire law recognizes a form of fusion voting that allows a candidate to appear on the ballot multiple times if they either petition on as independents and later win a party’s primary, as the two did, or if they similarly win multiple party nominations. To win a party’s nomination through write-in votes, a candidate needs at least 35 votes or 10 percent of the ballots cast in that party’s primary, whichever is lower. However, candidates who lose a primary in which their names appear on the ballot cannot accept another party’s nomination, even if they receive enough write-in votes.
The practice has been utilized by major and minor party candidates alike, including during the 2022 election cycle, when two candidates who originally petitioned their way onto the ballot for Hillsborough County Treasurer and County Attorney as Libertarians successfully won their respective Democratic Party primaries after no Democrats stepped forward. While they both lost the general election, they would go on to break 44 percent of the vote against incumbent Republicans.
It’s not officially confirmed how the three legislators intend to caucus in the New Hampshire Legislature. Following the general election, the Democratic Party controls a majority of seats in both the House and Senate, representing a sizeable shift from the Republican-controlled Legislature seen the last two years.
During the most recent legislative cycle, New Hampshire had only one independent legislator, although he was not elected as such. State Rep. Aidan Ankarberg, who represented Strafford County’s 7th District in Rochester’s Ward 3, was reelected as a Republican in 2024 before changing his affiliation to independent shortly afterward. Ankarberg said the change was intended to signal his support for an alternative candidate for House Speaker instead of incumbent Republican Sherman Packard.


Be First to Comment