Two independent candidates individually earned more votes than the margin separating Democrat Victoria Broderick and incumbent Republican Scott DesJarlais in the race for Tennessee’s 4th Congressional District, which went uncalled for nearly two weeks after Election Day.
According to unofficial results published by the Tennessee Secretary of State, independent Jacob Kristopher Anders received 2,833 votes, or roughly 1.45 percent of the total, while fellow independent Clay Faircloth earned another 1,853 votes, or just under 1 percent. Together, the two received 4,686 votes, far surpassing an initial margin of just several hundred votes separating Broderick and DesJarlais.
The margin only widened following the counting of outstanding provisional ballots in Nashville, expanding the total in Broderick’s favor and leading DesJarlais to concede earlier this week. She becomes the only Democrat to win a Tennessee congressional district this cycle.
Tennessee’s 4th Congressional District
| Candidate Name | Total Votes | Vote Percentage | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Victoria Broderick | Democratic | 95,585 | 48.87% |
| Scott DesJarlais | Republican | 95,305 | 48.73% |
| Jacob Kristopher Anders | Independent | 2,833 | 1.45% |
| Clay Faircloth | Independent | 1,853 | 0.95% |
Anders, an author and historian from Tullahoma, originally sought the Democratic nomination but was disqualified from the party’s primary under its rules governing what it calls bona fide candidates. He pivoted to an independent candidacy in response, discussing the circumstances of his disqualification and later legal challenge in an interview with Independent Political Report in June.
Faircloth, a counselor and ordained minister, previously sought the Democratic nomination in Tennessee’s 6th Congressional District in 2022 and 2024 before mounting his independent candidacy in the 4th District this year. Both candidates were required to submit nominating petitions containing at least 25 valid signatures from registered voters residing in counties wholly or partially within the district to qualify for the general election ballot.
While the 4th District has existed for much of Tennessee’s history, taking many different forms over the years, the results of the 2026 general election represent the first instance Independent Political Report has identified since the 19th century in which a candidate won the district with less than a majority of the vote. The most recent earlier example dates back to 1849, when Democrat John Savage won with 48.4 percent against Samuel Turney, whose partisan affiliation is unknown in historical records, with 38.8 percent, and Whig John Rogers with 12.8 percent.


Be First to Comment