Mike Shipley at Outright Libertarians:
We’ve taken some criticism from people who take the Indiana RFRA at face value, assuming that because it claims to stand for religious freedom, anybody who opposes it is in favor of the enslavement of bakers and florists. This could not be farther from the truth – it is possible to oppose both bigotry, and bad law, and still be libertarian. In fact, we feel it is a moral imperative to do so!!
Bigotry is not “speech”. Its source is the heart and mind, not the voice. If we feel that liberty is worth our efforts to persuade and enlighten, why not issues of social stigma as well? It’s irrational to leap from freedom of association to a pro-bigotry stance. They represent two very different organizing principles.
The market is proving its power to solve a problem the state created in Indiana. We should be pointing to that and saying “We told you so”, not taking the wrong side and shilling for bigots. Unfortunately, many of our allies in the libertarian movement bring with them a vulnerability to deceptive right-wing rhetoric. This attempt to cloak an establishment of religion in “freedom” is one of those times.

Sorry, couldn’t help it 🙂
Is that the new Apple product?
>ll that the law says is that if it’s ILLEGAL, a compelling state interest, applied as narrowly as >possible, would have to be demonstrated to sustain that illegality and any claim pursuant to >that illegality, whether it’s the state itself suing or being sued or not.
Well, it seems to me to say less than that. It seems to say that if it’s illegal, and I discriminated because of personal reasons, then the court should rule that it’s illegal. On the other hand, if it’s illegal and I discriminated for religious reasons, then the court should apply the strict scrutiny you reference. IANAL, but that’s what I see – and I don’t see that it instructs the court to overturn the law, just to not apply it in this case. Another case can come in the next day, and if it wasn’t for religious reasons, then the verdict is different.
Which brings up the question – why wouldn’t everyone say “it’s for religion?” Obviously, they would if they’re smart – so now courts get to decide what is a real religion and what isn’t.
“I can be forced as an employee to deny service on behalf of a religious employer”
Highly unlikely. Like I said, I’ve read the law. There’s nothing in there at all forbidding you to quit your job if you don’t like it.
The way I understand it, the law expands these protections to corporate entities by redefining the word “person”, while denying employees – actual people – a claim under them. So in that way too, it places wealthy bigots on a pedestal over poor ones. I can be forced as an employee to deny service on behalf of a religious employer, but I cannot assert a religious defense as an employee where I previously would have been protected. An mormon employer who drug tests to enforce a policy of abstinence, for example, may now fire a rastafarian employee who smokes spiritual marijuana. (In this example I am ignoring the federal law, which I believe would kick in in this case, since we are examining the effect of the Indiana law.)
Mike,
Your questions are interesting, but they open with an error.
“That’s not 100% true”
Yes, it is. Each and every one of your questions was just as valid before the law as it is after the law.
Which part of “this law has no content” is unclear?
My only qualm with the Indiana law was that it granted religious people exclusive rights to do what anyone should be allowed to do.
Forcing a business transaction between two private parties is not a legitimate function of government.
(Disclaimer: The above comment is not intended, and ought not be construed, to condone forcing people to bake any quantity of cakes greater than zero. It is meant to illuminate the idea that the existence of gay Christians is being invisibilized by a debate which polarizes the issue in a way which favors one specific doctrine to the detriment of the religious freedom of others. And that’s the hallmark of a poorly written statute that fails to meet the basic standard for an egalitarian system of law.)
Knappster: It adds nothing to existing law, nor does it take anything away.
That’s not 100% true, religion *IS* a protected class in Indiana. I don’t want to get into theology but there’s a teaching in the bible about how we’re all equal in the eyes of God … we are all His children. “There is no Jew or Gentile” … I believe in the same way, there is no gay or straight. Do I now have a compelling argument before the court that hindering my equal access to the market is a burden on my religious freedom? It’s also not spiritual to refuse coercion, “If you are forced to bake a cake, bake them two” per another teaching regarding the Roman oppressors, but somebody could use either of these in court (I wouldn’t, because I believe the lesson of liberating us from Leviticus is precisely that mixing church and state is a horrible idea). None of these are orthodox interpretations, but they are my sincerely held beliefs. Will the state choose the doctrine of hate as the one more significantly burdened than mine? What if I was an atheist, saying that my freedom of conscience requires me to exclude Christians? Is my non-religion also protected, or is it not a religion, analogous to the way not collecting stamps is obviously not a hobby? And why are the courts in a position to weigh these beliefs against one another? I think the law does tip the balance of the scale of justice in a way that places some bigots on a pedestal “more equal” than others while robbing bigots who aren’t not religious at all of their freedom of conscience.
Bruce: Hey Mike — there may be a demand for a video. I know I need the money….
Bring on the catfight and the KY wrestling!! We may have a hit YouTube channel on our hands.
“What about the provision in Section 9 that specifically says ‘whether or not the government is a party?'”
What about it?
Party A complains that Party B has discriminated. That discrimination is either legal or it’s illegal (in Indiana, if Party A is complaining that Party B discriminated because Party A is LGBTQ, it’s legal). All that the law says is that if it’s ILLEGAL, a compelling state interest, applied as narrowly as possible, would have to be demonstrated to sustain that illegality and any claim pursuant to that illegality, whether it’s the state itself suing or being sued or not.
That’s nothing new. It adds nothing to existing law, nor does it take anything away.
I also sense, ironically, a threat to the freedom of religion, since the net effect will be courts deciding what is a ‘real’ or ‘legitimate’ religion and what isn’t.
TK – What about the provision in Section 9 that specifically says “whether or not the government is a party?” This seems to contradict your summary above. Certainly I agree with your last statement. I’d add that, if it did legalize discrimination by private actors (on an equal footing) I’d have no real problem with it, depending on the details. I’d even have no problem if it legalized discrimination against some groups and not others. I would have a problem if it legalized discrimination by some groups and not others, or if it protects some group from being sued, without so protecting others.
Yes but it makes a better wedge and fund raising issue to say you will protect us gays against the mean people.
Joshua,
I’ve never read the federal RFRA. I’ve read the Indiana law. There’s no “there” there. There’s nothing in the law that wasn’t already settled law.
One thing that seems to be confusing people is that the Indiana RFRA “legalizes discrimination against LGBTQ people.” It doesn’t. Discrimination against LGBTQ people has never been illegal in Indiana.
TK, it sounds like you’re describing the federal RFRA (which demonstrated that some Democrats wanted to reach out to the religious.) The Indiana version, to my understanding, provided an affirmative defense against prosecution, including lawsuits where the state was not a party.
Well, there WOULD be a problem with the RFRA only protecting religious freedom, if the RFRA protected religious freedom. But it doesn’t. It doesn’t protect anything.
Yes, it says that if someone sues claiming their religious freedom is “burdened” by this or that restriction, the state has to either lift the restriction or demonstrate 1) a “compelling interest” in having the restriction, and 2) that the restriction is the most “narrow” means of achieving that compelling interest.
But that’s already the standard for litigation concerning allegedly rights-violating restrictions, whether the right allegedly being violated is the right to free exercise of religion or not.
The RFRA changes nothing. The RFRA does one, and only one, thing: It signals to social conservative voters that the GOP is still on their side. That’s all it does, and that’s all it was meant to do.
I think there is a problem with the RFRA in that only those with religious credentials have their freedom of association protected. No one is a slave to someone else’s desires, and no one should be forced by government to do much of anything. Further, although I completely disagree with the original post that refusing to do something against one’s principles makes one a bigot or a hater, every indvidual does, in fact, have the right to be a bigot or hater. But no individual has the right to use force to impel another to do his bidding.
The issue of “marriage equality” is simple. Get the government out of the marriage business altogether, and protect everyone’s unalienable right to contract. Then let the invisible hand of the market operate. There will be hundreds of niche businesses catering to different kinds of weddings, and no one need force someone to cater to a wedding they are not capable of serving cheerfully. I could happily cater a gay wedding, but I would draw the line at catering a Christian Identity wedding, or even that of two hot-farting fundamentalists.
That’s the way my particular prejudices roll.
Hey Mike — there may be a demand for a video. I know I need the money….
Thanks! It’s now on my to-do list. I gotta get ready for work, so other IPR writers are welcome to beat me to it, as well.
Good idea.
That depends on the meaning of y’all, y’all. While personally it is true I would rather see Julie and Cathy make out, others such as Jed Ziggler and Andy Craig may have different preferences. Watching two guys make out is not exciting for me, but I got over being bothered by it some time around high school age iirc.
Sure Paulie post if you want. I’m writing a longer piece that I may try to give to reason or the Daily Caller today. My plot is that Mike and I can get booked as an act, like Julie Borowski and Cathy Reisenwitz, at SFL/YAL/LP events, where we end up slapping each other and then making out. Unfortunately I suspect y’all would rather see Julie and Cathy do that. Oh well….
…I see no reason that it is legitimate to privilege the right of religious business owners to discriminate. Since we’ve established the general legal principle that business owners cannot choose their customers (which I think is wrong) this amounts to special pleading for a special subset of business owners. I object to that.
I agree that religion should have nothing to do with it. In fact, as I mentioned on another thread here the other day, I think from a purely libertarian standpoint, there is really no such thing as freedom of religion, at least not per se, since the NAP makes no distinction between religious actions and non-religious actions. Aggression is still wrong, even if it’s part of a religion, and vice versa.
I realize my comments above could be taken as support for the RFRA, but that was not my intent. Rather, I was trying to make the general point that libertarianism says nothing about whether any particular cultural stance should be responded to with boycotts, ostracism, etc.
Check out this story. A Colorado bakery refused to bake a cake with an anti-gay message on it, and they were found to not be guilty of discrimination.
I don’t think that a person should be forced to bake a cake with any message on it that they do not like, however, it sure seems hypocritical that it is not OK for a baker to refuse to bake a cake for a gay wedding but it is OK for a baker to refuse to bake a cake with an anti-gay message on it.
How about let people decide for themselves which messages they are willing to put on a cake and forget all of this political bullshit? This is supposed to be a free country.
https://www.yahoo.com/politics/azucar-bakery-did-not-discriminate-by-refusing-to-115703680320.html
Let’s say that the Church of Satan is having a party and they want to purchase a cake. Suppose they go into a bake shop that is owned by a Christian and they say that they want to order a cake that has an upside down pentagram on it, and they want “Hail Satan” written over the upside down pentagram. If the Christian baker refuses to bake a cake with this symbol and message on it should the Church of Satan members be able to file a complaint with the Labor Bureau and get the bakery shut down as a result?
How about if some Neo Nazis went into a bakery owned by a Jewish person and they wanted a cake to celebrate Adolf Hitler’s birthday? Suppose they wanted to have a Swastika in the middle of the cake, with the words “Happy Birthday Adolf Hitler” around the Swastika. Should the Jewish baker be fined $150,000 if they refuse to make a cake like this?
Excellent response from Bruce Majors.
The main issue, for me as a libertarian, is highlighted by Rick Santorum’s speech in favor of the law. He asked if a gay baker should be forced to bake a cake that says “God hates fags.” I say – of course not. But (I’m not a lawyer) whatever the legal status of that question was before RFRA, it remains the same after RFRA, since the gay person is not refusing on the basis of a religious objection. And that is my issue – I see no reason that it is legitimate to privilege the right of religious business owners to discriminate. Since we’ve established the general legal principle that business owners cannot choose their customers (which I think is wrong) this amounts to special pleading for a special subset of business owners. I object to that.
“Libertarianism is about the legitimate use of force. It has nothing to say about cultural issues.”
True. Libertarianism has nothing to say about cultural issues.
But libertarians, being people, do. And it is only natural that libertarians, being people, will want to associate with people of like mind on issues other than libertarianism itself.
Personally I reject “thick libertarianism” — the attempt to shoehorn this or that value above, beyond or instead of non-aggression into the definition of libertarianism.
But that doesn’t mean I’m required to make common cause — beyond defending their rights — with people who, while they may in fact be libertarians, are for some other reason or reasons unattractive to me as comrades or companions.
I have no desire to force cake bigots to bake for same-sex weddings, because I’m a libertarian. But if I know they ARE cake bigots, I won’t be dropping in for pastries myself either. Not because I’m a libertarian, but because I don’t like that kind of bigot.
Bigotry *IS* social activism!! It is simply boycott/ostracism from another perspective.
I think that’s quite a stretch. “Social activism” as commonly understood (boycott, ostracism, etc.) has as its goal the changing of societal values, norms, and so forth. While there may be a few bigoted groups (KKK, neo-Nazis, etc.) who have that as the goal behind their bigotry, the vast majority of those being described as “bigots” (such as the “pizza bigots” from Indiana mentioned in the title) do not seem to have any such desire. They simply do not wish to be around people they do not like, or who make them uncomfortable. That’s pretty much the definition of freedom of association, and I don’t see how it is any different than the examples that Bruce gave of LGBT groups wishing to exclude non-LGBT individuals from certain places.
The question is, why should we uphold that right for bigots, and discourage it for LGBT folks?
I’m not sure who is saying we should. I’m certainly not. I’m saying we should uphold freedom of association for all groups. And as for boycotts, ostracism, etc., there is nothing wrong with libertarians engaging in those activities, for whatever reason they choose. But to imply that those activities should somehow be considered part of the “libertarian agenda” is simply false. Libertarianism is about the legitimate use of force. It has nothing to say about cultural issues.
Bigotry *IS* social activism!! It is simply boycott/ostracism from another perspective. And not only does libertarianism not forbid it, but as far as economics go we recognize it is a routine part of the human experience. We make decisions every day based on our own values. The question is, why should we uphold that right for bigots, and discourage it for LGBT folks? The idea that this is somehow a forbidden subject for libertarians makes Outright’s job as a two-way bridge between the two communities so much more difficult than it should be. And that is why I see value in raising an awareness that is contradictory to the idea that somehow bigoted free speech is “more equal” than any other.
Agreed!
The LP platform actually names boycott and ostracism explicitly as the correct forms of market activism to remedy social injustices, and I agree with that assessment.
While libertarians (or anyone else) should of course be free to engage in such tactics, they are under no obligation to do so. Libertarianism does not require social activism, no matter how much some people wish it did.
It’s irrational to leap from freedom of association to a pro-bigotry stance.
I’m not sure whether I agree with this. I guess it depends on what the rather nebulous phrase “pro-bigotry stance” entails. If it means applauding bigotry, then I agree, that’s irrational. If, on the other hand, it simply means defending the right to engage in bigotry (so long, of course, as such bigotry doesn’t constitute aggression), then libertarians should definitely take a “pro-bigotry” stance.
I also agree that Bruce Majors makes a lot of excellent points.
There are a number of very good reasons for diverse peoples to control their spaces for a specific environment. For example, a fetish prom excluding people in street clothes, a church service excluding people in fetish gear, a lesbian bar excluding straight men, and more. There have also been some grave injustices, for example the leather bar which was sued for excluding a drag queen, and the case of the photographer in New Mexico which I found particularly disturbing. However, I’m not sure how the RFRA requires me as a libertarian to refrain from observing that it initiates coercive force in a way which robs, for example, atheists of their right to exclude Christians. I’m also not sure why anybody would expect a gay man to abandon a conversation about social stigmas in favor of a bigot-centric conversation that places the desire to exclude me from civil society in a position of superiority over my own experience. The LP platform actually names boycott and ostracism explicitly as the correct forms of market activism to remedy social injustices, and I agree with that assessment. Why wouldn’t I celebrate that and give libertarianism credit for having the correct solution when that solution demonstrates its power, just because there are people in our movement who want to tiptoe around the delicate feelings of the bigots in our midst? Let the bigots speak for themselves – as they are not shy about doing. I am going to stand up for marginalized peoples and use my voice to create an LGBT-centric narrative about free association that favors our interests. Not to the exclusion of other voices, but with the dignity of knowing our voices are equal.
Great piece by Mike, great response by Bruce.
Damn, Bruce. That’s an excellent comment. I absolutely agree with you.
Bruce,
Let me know if you would like me to post that as a response article.
There are lots of gay businesses that exclude non-gays, and lesbian events that exclude even gay men or transgender people: Olivia cruises, Atlantis cruises, the Michigan Womyn’s music festival, many gay B&Bs (I’ve been at one in Ft. Lauderdale and seen them turn away a straight couple, who I assume were named something like Pat and Chris, who had reservations). I really think straight people should now sue all of these businesses out of existence, just to make the point that if you want to begin outlawing all freedom of association (and freedom of belief) then two can play that game. Developers are just beginning to discuss gay oriented nursing homes and 55+ communities, so let’s nip that in the bud too. (The list is endless – gay oriented health care providers, etc. etc.)
Not wanting to be with straight or gay or bisexual people in all situations doesn’t make you a bigot. When my (married, heterosexual) female doctor left DC for Palo Alto, I had to find a new doctor. I finally settled on her medical partner, a frighteningly good looking married heterosexual guy. But I had to think about what kind of person, about the many doctors available, I would feel most comfortable having their hands on (and in) me: a man, a woman, someone attractive, someone not attractive, gay, straight. (The answer is I don’t really like having any of these people in this situation — but I’d hate to be forced to accept one – or have them accept me or anyone that made them uncomfortable.) I think there are lots of sensitive areas, from kindergartens to nursing homes, where the idea that we should force or even shame people into accepting what they aren’t (maybe yet) comfortable with, is malicious. And I don’t think we get to decide for other people which services – tailors, hair stylists, shoe salesman, algebra teachers, etc. – are sensitive of not.
Meanwhile, the failed civil rights paradigm grinds on, trying to identify new “protected classes” it can make money and acquire more power protecting by forcing you to share a locker room.
African Americans, the original intended beneficiaries, have double digit unemployment and are often trapped in failed, de facto segregated, school systems, where the rounding up and selling of poor children of color to the educrat cartels funds the candidates of the political party most wedded to the failed civil rights paradigm. And real moves to inclusion and equality occur because of innovations in the market, like Uber or Lyft, where you hire and pay for a ride and get it regardless of color, while taxi cabs that are regulated as an alleged public accommodation under civil rights law pass you by based on your race or zip code, even though the civil rights regime supposedly prevents that.
We need to scrap the entire civil rights mythology and its priestly class (who so often point out that they are Reverends) and reformulate all such policies to be based on the ideas of individual self-ownership and all that it entails, including freedom of association.